The Exorcist
(The Version You've Never Seen)
U.S.A. / 1973 (2000)
Directed by William Friedkin
Starring
Ellen Burstyn
Max Von Sydow
Linda Blair
Color / 132 Minutes / R
Format: DVD 
(R1 - NTSC)
Warner Home Video
Hold your mouse pointer over an image for a pop-up caption
 
 
10
    6  
10 = Highest
Rating
 
Guest Review by Troy Howarth
Chris MacNeill (Ellen Burstyn) is an actress filming a movie in Georgetown, the tony section of Washington DC. Her young daughter, Regan (Linda Blair), begins exhibiting strange behavioral symptoms but nobody is able to figure out what the problem is. The little girl claims to be possessed by a demon, and the skeptical mother, in a state of hysteria, calls in a priest (Jason Miller) to investigate the matter further...
    Upon its release in 1973, William Friedkin's Oscar-nominated film of The Exorcist created a scandal that seems inconceivable in our modern, jaded climate. Adapted from William Peter Blatty's best-selling novel, Friedkin's film touched on deep-rooted religious fears and shocked viewers with its graphic depiction of demonic possession. Perhaps it was the image of apple-cheeked Linda Blair spewing profanity and masturbating with a crucifix that touched the nerves of viewers who never batted an eye at something so mundane as George Romero's zombies or the monsters of Universal and Hammer. An instant box office smash, the film became as controversial as it was critically lauded. Nominated for Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actress and a handful of other Academy Awards, it thus eclipsed such 'major' horror films as Roman Polanski's superior Rosemary's Baby (1968) in terms of critical accolades. Viewed today, one may wonder what the fuss was all about. It's not uncommon for younger viewers to laugh at it outright, though for many it retains a power to shock and chill. Speaking from personal experience, I have to confess to never finding the film particularly scary, but its merits as a film should be obvious.
    Friedkin, in 1973, was a director on a roll, moving from one excellent picture to the next — this was before his underrated remake of Henri-Georges Clouzot's Wages of Fear, Sorcerer, and his grotesquely misunderstood gay serial killer opus Cruising derailed his prominence in the film industry and sent him scurrying for cover. This film sees him at the top of his form, using his predilection for subliminal edits and aggressive, unfussy camerawork to perfection. More unsettling than the displays of demonic possession is a disquieting, eerie montage that shows the viewers the paranoid dreamscape of the tormented Father Karras (Jason Miller). The actual demonic possession angle is forcefully realized and so well known at this point that any recap would be pointless... Suffice it to say, Friedkin's imagery had such impact on moviegoers and filmmakers that a steady slew of imitations would flood forth in the ensuing years. Among other things, The Exorcist boasts one of the finest casts ever assembled for a horror film. Ellen Burstyn is superb as the initially bitchy mother who undergoes a breakdown as her daughter's behavior spins out of control; it's not the most glamorous role in the world, but Burstyn plays it to perfection. Swedish actor Max Von Sydow, something of an icon due to his work with Ingmar Bergman, is perfection itself as the haunted Father Merrin, the exorcist. Von Sydow, then in his 40s, is miraculously (and convincingly) made to resemble a much older man through the brilliant makeup work of Dick Smith. The venerable actor brings with him his 'luggage' as a spiritual character in Bergman's filmography and delivers a flawless performance that is both authoritative and subtly moving. Jason Miller, an acclaimed playwright and first-time actor, steals the film as the tormented Father Karras, while legendary character actor Lee J. Cobb (On the Waterfront, 12 Angry Men) steals a few scenes as the intrepid Lieutenant Kinderman. Irish character actor Jack MacGowran is hysterical as the drunken director Burke Dennings; alas, this was the Polanski veteran's last film — he died from complications of London Flu not long after finishing his scenes. (This was one of many incidents that led to rumors of an Exorcist 'curse'.)
    With its stark cinematography, incredible sound mix and music score and brilliant editing, The Exorcist is very good filmmaking indeed. Despite its obvious merits, the original director's cut of the film caused something of a rift between Friedkin and writer/producer William Peter Blatty. Blatty, who felt Friedkin's cut seemed too downbeat ("I didn't want the audience to think the devil won..."), long spoke of valuable material that had been cut in interviews and in 2000, he was finally able to present his preferred cut to the public. The differences between the two cuts have been noted, debated and discussed to death by this point, leaving the question: which version works better? I can only answer that, while I felt Friedkin's cut was a solid film, I found myself far more affected by the "version I never saw." It restores some valuable character bits, notably fleshing out Von Sydow's performance and allowing him to express something of a human side. The new cut is not perfect — regretfully, the new technology allowed Blatty and Friedkin to insert subliminal digital effects which draw too much attention to themselves and the reinsertion of the infamous "spider walk" feels too much like a cheap scare, effective enough on its own terms but somehow tacky in so stately a film.
    Pockmarks aside, the 2000 cut strikes me as a stronger presentation as a whole, thus securing its place among the greatest horror films of all time.

Warner Brothers' DVD presentation of The Version You've Never Seen is a thing of beauty, with a crisp, remastered image that looks as if it were shot yesterday. The film has been properly matted to 1.85 and is enhanced for widescreen TVs. Audio quality is also superb, showing off a new surround remix to its best advantage. In terms of extras, however, it falls way short of the 25th anniversary presentation of the 1973 cut. Missing is the superb Fear of God documentary and in place of the dynamic audio commentary with Friedkin and Blatty we get a mind-numbingly dull commentary with Friedkin who monotonously explains the action to the viewer as it unfolds before them! This "film for the blind" style narration doesn't merit any further comment... Disappointing extras to one side, this is still a fine presentation in terms of A/V and is worth a purchase on that level alone, depending, of course, on one's take on the different cuts of the film. 11/29/03
HOME | REVIEWS | TOP