PRIVATE
Italy | 2003
Directed by Tinto Brass
Starring
Sara Cosmi
Maruska Albertazzi
Federica Palmer
Color | 87 Minutes | Not Rated
Format: DVD (R1 - NTSC)
Cult Epics
Hold your mouse pointer over an image for a pop-up caption

Buy online

at Amazon
 
 
Review by
Troy Howarth

Film:7
:
DVD:8
Tinto Brass presents a series of erotic vignettes... In the first story, Gianni (Massimiliano Caroletti) and Cinzia (Sara Cosmi) are on holiday in Morocco; worried that the zest is leaving their sex life, Gianni arranges for Cinzia to have an affair as he watches. In the second story, Stefania (Silvia Rossi) has sex with Bruno (Max Parodi), in order to get back at her husband (Andrea Nobili)… who is also screwing Bruno's wife (Federica Tommasi) behind his back. The next tale depicts an ambitious maid, Katarina (Raffaella Ponzo), who sleeps with the clients at her hotel in exchange for tips. The next segment sees Rafaela (Angela Ferlaino) cheating on her husband, Ugo (Daniele Ferrari), because he secretly enjoys hearing about her trysts. Next up, Franco (Riccardo Marino) wants nothing more than to have anal sex with his girlfriend, Anna (Maruska Albertazzi), but she insists on keeping the back door closed until they're married. And in the last, Rosy (Federica Palmer) and Oskar (Roberto Giulianelli) have sex for the benefit of a secret voyeur, whose real identity is finally revealed at the end.
    Giovanni "Tinto" Brass made his first foray into experimental cinema in 1958; after that, he tried his hand at a variety of popular genres (gialli, with Deadly Sweet, 1968; spaghetti westerns, with Yankee, 1966), but his forte was soon established with erotica. Though many of his early works had ample doses of sex and nudity, it was Salon Kitty (1976) which sealed his fate as a purveyor of artfully composed smut. Make no mistake — Brass is no 'mere' pornographer, but the director has long admitted that the difference between respectable erotica and flat-out hardcore porn is tentative at best. Private (originally Fallo!, a play on "Do It" and the phallic symbol) is one of the director's more recent films, and it pushes the boundaries between softcore and hardcore in an aggressive manner. Yes, much of the sex is simulated. Yes, most of the (imposing) boners on display are prosthetics. But for all that, there's ample graphic interplay on display — and at least one authentic blowjob.
    The segments vary in effectiveness, but the film is never dull. There are numerous reasons for this. For one, the actresses on display are terrific to look at and they all enter into the spirit of the thing with ample enthusiasm. For another, Brass never allows the action to get too repetitive. There's a little something for just about everybody here: lesbianism, breast/ass/foot fetishism, S&M, etc, etc. Like all good directors of erotic cinema, Brass understands tempo and pacing — he shows just enough to get the juices flowing, but he pulls back from going too far. There's no doubt this qualifies as hardcore, but there are no (real) ejaculations, and penetrations are implied rather than graphically shown. On top of all this, the film simply looks wonderful. Brass is a great stylist — he knows how to use color, composition, camera movement and music to create the right rhythm. Even at its weakest — and I would argue that the second story is distinctly less impressive than the rest of the material, even if it is the one that contains the most graphic sex (including the aforementioned oral number) — the film holds one's interest and moves along at a good pace.
    The performances are in synch with the film's light, playful mood. It's truly hard to narrow down the actresses in terms of sheer aesthetic value, but certainly Sara Cosmi, Raffaella Ponzo, Maruska Albertazzi, Federica Palmer and Angela Ferlaino are all stunning beauties in their own right. Many of these actresses have worked with Brass on other occasions (Cosmi made her debut in P.O. Box Tinto Brass, 1995, for example) but few of them are recognizable outside of the Euro-Erotica context. Raffaella Ponzo did have a bit part in Martin Scorsese's Italian-lensed epic Gangs of New York (2002), but she surely had better opportunity to show off her assets under Brass' tutelage!
    Ultimately the film may be rather minor compared to its director's major works (Salon Kitty, 1983's The Key) but it's still a fun and stylish slice of erotica. In a genre overrun with cheap trash, it's wonderful to have a serious artist who takes the genre seriously — while at the same time possessing enough humor to keep things light and playful.

Cult Epics has released both the uncensored director's cut and the R-rated producer's cut of Private; the version under review here is Brass' cut. The 1.85/16x9 transfer looks wonderful. Colors are vivid, detail is very strong, and print damage is negligible. The film is fully uncut, and the mastering job is topnotch, with only some minor shimmering in evidence. The Italian soundtrack is full blooded, preserving all the heavy breathing. Extras include a fun behind the scenes featurette (seeing Brass cavort with his actresses just makes one realize what a lucky old guy he really is!), a trailer, and two stills galleries — one dedicated to the 'X rated' images in the film. 10/21/10
UPDATE This title seems to have been pulled from the market in February 2011.
HOME | REVIEWS | TOP